The article investigates how Indian consumers of footwear perceive and trust various
marketplaces (Amazon, Flipkart and Myntra) in comparison to the brands’ own websites, with
Bata India as the focal brand. The study has relied on a sample of 178 respondents for
gathering data via a structured questionnaire aiming to cover the aspects of trust perception,
platform identity, trust drivers and promotion sensitivity. It was found that brand websites
receive significantly higher trust (M = 3.54) in comparison to marketplaces (M = 3.42, p =
.011), although the difference does not seem too large. However, in spite of the high level of
trust, which would lead to buying from the brand sites in line with theories about trust,
marketplaces are still winning the purchase war. Thus, while 73.6% of respondents are usually
buying shoes from Myntra or Flipkart, the contradiction is evident and consumers are trusting
brands more than marketplaces, with 56.7% of respondents believing that the brand’s website
is the best representation of the brand’s identity. Moreover, the research has shown that secure
payment, overall customer support and speed of the website seem to be the strongest
preconditions of brand trust, while product images and descriptions attract much lesser
attention in terms of their importance. The survey indicates that consumers prefer brand trust
to discounts, as respondents indicated with a mean score of 4.18, while also keeping in mind
that consumers respond well to sales. The other point worth mentioning is that the study found
that over half (about 58%) of respondents cited reviews and ratings — a feature native to the
marketplace — as the main determinant of trust as compared to product quality or brand name.
The study therefore provides Bata India with recommendations regarding the strengthening
of its brand trust with the help of authenticity assurance, customer support, and review
visibility on its website to stimulate purchases.