The digital age has revolutionized communication, granting individuals the unprecedented ability to express their views to global audiences. However, this democratization of speech has also brought forth complex challenges in distinguishing between protected free speech and impermissible hate speech. This paper critically analyzes the legal, social, and ethical dimensions of free speech and hate speech on digital platforms. It explores how different jurisdictions balance these competing interests, evaluates the role of digital intermediaries, and examines the effectiveness and implications of current regulatory frameworks. The paper concludes with recommendations for a more nuanced and context-sensitive approach to regulating online speech.